Should You Buy or Rent Your Heavy Equipment?


Having the necessary heavy equipment and machinery is essential for a construction company to run efficiently. Every job differs, as do the equipment requirements. Factors like project demands and financial considerations will influence your decision to rent or buy heavy equipment. Expanding your inventory is a step in the right direction, but there are other options to consider before fully committing.

Keep reading for a breakdown of the pros and cons of renting or buying heavy equipment.

Advantages of Renting Heavy Equipment

Renting heavy equipment is a great option for a variety of reasons, such as:

  • Flexibility: Renting is beneficial if you need heavy equipment for short-term projects or projects that have no specific deadline. It offers flexibility and scalability to handle sporadic jobs. There is no commitment to long-term ownership contracts and no monthly installments to repay so you can utilize the equipment on a needs basis.
  • Selection: With rental options, you have access to a diverse range of specialized equipment built with the latest technology suited to your specific project needs.
  • Cost savings: Renting is a cost-effective alternative when you are unsure regarding delivery time frames. Further savings include lower liability and savings on insurance, maintenance and depreciation costs.
  • Reliability: Maintenance is the owner's responsibility, so you have peace of mind knowing the equipment is in good condition. If you experience a breakdown, you can often request a replacement — this helps you maintain project timelines and ensures maximum efficiency.

There are, however, certain reasons why renting heavy equipment might not be the best choice, including:

  • Renting usually comes with higher costs for more frequent use or long-term contracts.
  • You might encounter limited equipment availability due to high demand or during peak seasons.
  • There are restrictions on the modifications and customizations you can make to the machinery.

Advantages of Buying Heavy Equipment

While renting has its advantages, buying your own heavy equipment has its own. One major advantage of buying heavy equipment is the financial implications associated with doing so. The initial cost to purchase equipment is high, but owning equipment means you'll save on costs in the long term, especially for bigger projects that have longer deadlines.

While there is always the risk of equipment breaking, you have the option to purchase service and maintenance plans that will help you keep them in running condition. With time, your equipment will pay itself off and you will reap the rewards.

Other advantages to purchasing heavy equipment include:

  • Like vehicles, machinery and equipment may depreciate over time — however, in some cases, your equipment might appreciate and have a higher resale value because of their inherent worth as assets that aren't easily dispensed.
  • Owned equipment that is not rented is readily available for use to commence any project type and size, reducing delays and saving time and money.
  • As the owner, you are able to modify and customize your equipment to implement parts and components that will enhance usability.
  • You have control over the service and maintenance schedule, ensuring the longevity of your equipment.
  • Trained and experienced operators are increasingly efficient and productive when they use the same equipment repeatedly, becoming familiar with its operation.
  • As an owner, renting out your surplus heavy equipment is possible as a means to generate extra income, depending on supply and demand in the industry.

factors to consider when you purchase heavy equipment

Key Factors to Consider

Your decision to rent or purchase your own heavy equipment will be influenced by a few determinants. Here are some of the key factors:

  • Finance options: Cash may be king, but it's not always available for large purchases like heavy equipment. Financing may be easier on the pocketbook, but the interest rates and high installments associated with it may become overbearing, especially if equipment remains idle. Weigh the pros and cons of using cash to rent versus purchasing with a finance plan as it may be job dependent, amongst other things.
  • Business forecasting: Owners understand the direction their company is going and consider growth and demand. Based on this, heavy equipment purchasing patterns may vary as the business expands.
  • Regulatory requirements: As newer equipment is introduced, older models may become redundant. Regulatory and compliance requirements change accordingly, meaning you need to adhere if you own the equipment. Training may be needed to keep staff skilled and informed and regular OSHA inspections ensure you remain compliant.
  • Project duration and scope: The size and complexity of any given project will determine whether you want to invest in renting or buying heavy equipment to complete it. Some contracts provide long-term job opportunities that may last years, while others are short-lived and last a few weeks. It might be feasible to rent for smaller jobs in this case.
  • Intended purpose: Renting or buying usually depends on what you use specific types of heavy equipment for and the frequency of use. Contractors who mainly work with cement will benefit from purchasing concrete mixers, drum rollers and other equipment used in the construction industry. Buying would be a better option if you specialize in a field that requires specific equipment used often, as you'll see a return on your investment over time. You might rent equipment that has highly specialized use cases you won't need for many projects.
  • Equipment storage and transportation: Renting versus buying has different implications concerning storage and transportation. Jobs that require rental equipment to be transported from storage to site are usually costly, especially if multiple pieces of equipment must be delivered to different sites. You might benefit from renting some equipment if you already own others, since this may reduce transport costs and storage fees if the jobs overlap.
  • Financial capacity for repairs: If anything goes wrong and rental equipment breaks in your care, you may be held liable for the damages. Some companies claim responsibility for repairs because they must maintain their own equipment. If you own heavy equipment, you are responsible for repairing them. It is beneficial to have reserve funding in place in case this happens but it's not always possible. One way to mitigate the costs is by extending warranties on your equipment so you don't have to worry about having cash when it breaks down.

Rent or Buy Your Heavy Equipment From Stephenson Equipment

Owning versus renting heavy equipment has pros and cons. Overall, renting is ideal for short-term projects that are less demanding, while you will enjoy the benefits of owning equipment if you specialize in a certain field that requires constant use of specific equipment.

When it comes to deciding whether renting or buying is better, carefully evaluate the project requirements and how either option will impact you financially. Consult with industry experts like Stephenson Equipment to determine the best way forward based on your current situation. We will ensure you get the most value for your money, whatever you choose.

Visit any of our branches or contact us online with your request details. We'll get back to you as soon as possible to discuss your needs.

rent or buy heavy equipment